Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (2024)

Posted on by Emily 33 Comments. This post may contain affiliate links. Clicking and purchasing through them helps to keep the great content coming your way, thanks! Find all my favorite items in my Amazon SHOP HERE. Posts written in collaboration of Brother as a Brother Brand Ambassador.

Pin

Share

Tweet

Share

Inside: find lots of ideas for the best pie iron recipes. Make meals for all times of the day with these great ideas.

We love camping as a family, and especially when we eat pie iron recipes while out. You can also make these over your backyard fire if you aren’t a camper. This post is full of ideas for meals to make in a pie iron, but I would bet that after reading this you will also be inspired to create your own tasty pie cooker meals.

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (1)

One weekend while camping I made the best pie iron recipes for our family. You can also make these recipes with a pie maker in your backyard.

We were fortunate to go camping over Easter weekend. I decided that we would only eat pie iron recipes for the whole weekend. So I planned out the meals and we ate some yummy camp food that weekend. We camp backpacking style…. so we have minimal gear.

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (2)

We cook over an open fire and the pie iron is great for this style of cooking. {it also is super fun for a backyard campfire if you aren’t a camper!} Here are a few photos from our camping on the beach over the years… every one carries their own weight… even the little ones carry something {even if its just the sand toys! } These pictures are all older…

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (3)

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (4)

How to use a Pie Iron / Pie Cooker

Ok, let’s get to the food! I loved that I was able to prep SO much at home for these meals! First, lets talk pie iron basics.. you need two slices of bread for each pie and the bread should be larger than the iron. Butter one side of each slice of bread {that side will go against the iron.}

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (5)

Put your toppings on that slice of bread and then top with the other slice, butter side up {again towards the iron} Make your sandwich as desired {lots of ideas below!} and place in pie iron. Trim excess bread from edges.

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (6)

Place in fire over coals, cook on one side, then turn and cook on the other. You can buy pie irons online at Amazon or in stores in the camping section. Some are too thin and the pies burn easily, so get a decent one. You will want to check your bread frequently to prevent burning while you get the hang of cooking with a pie cooker.

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (7)

Pie Iron Recipe Ideas

1. Campfire Cheeseburger Pies

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (8)

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (9)

Yield: 04

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (10)

Cheeseburger pies are a huge hit with everyone. Make on your next camping trip or backyard fire night.

Ingredients

  • 1 lb ground beef
  • cheese slices
  • 8 slices bread
  • butter
  • toppings of your choice.. ketchup, mustard, veggies etc...

Instructions

  1. Prep meat at home. Pre cook in a pan and season to liking. Place in a container.
  2. Slice cheese and place in bag.

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (11)

2. Breakfast Egg Pie

Ingredients-

  • Eggs {1 per sandwich}
  • Slices of cheese
  • Bread {2 per sandwich}
  • Bacon
  • Pre-cooked veggies {optional}

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (13)So for this recipe I usually pre-cook the bacon at home or cook it in a pan on the fire. This just makes the whole breakfast cooking go faster. However, if you really want to only use pie cookers, you could cook the bacon in one half just like I do the eggs.

To prep the ingredients cook the bacon {at home or over the fire} and cook one egg in each side of your pie iron. Make sure to put lots of butter in the iron first, add the egg, give a little mix, then cook over the fire until firm.

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (14)

Now, place this egg square and some bacon on a piece of bread to create your pie. You can add veggies and cheese as well for an omelette pie.

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (15)

3. Pizza Pie Recipe

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (16)

Ingredients –

  • Bread {2 slices per pie}
  • Tomato Pizza Sauce
  • Pepperoni
  • Mozzarella cheese
  • Any other pizza toppings you want

Place tomato sauce and toppings between two slices of buttered bread and cook over the fire.

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (17)

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (18)

and there you go! You too can eat camping pies for a whole weekend! Some other Campfire Pie Ideas:

  • Fruit Pies {jam/pie filling and bread}
  • cinnamon rolls {open a tube of rolls and place on on a well greased pie cooker to bake in the fire}
  • Grilled Cheese {add onions, tomato avocado for a deluxe version}
  • Chicken cheese pockets {Pre-cooked chicken, cheese and spinach}
  • What else can you create??

Other camping posts I’ve shared..

this easy sewing tutorial for a kids sleeping bag.

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (19)

Campfire Cooking Recipes {different from this post}

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (20)

Campfire Cooking Ideas

20+ Easy Camping recipes

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (21)

Pin

Share

Tweet

Share

Related Posts:

  • The Best Soup Recipes from Life Sew Savory
  • Cracker spread recipes - easy appetizers
  • Best Baby Blanket Sewing Tutorials

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (25)

Subscribe for the latest

TIPS, TUTORIALS AND MORE STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX

Best Pie Iron Recipes - Life Sew Savory (2024)

FAQs

What is the world famous pie iron? ›

Rome is a 3 generation family business that began in 1964 when my father and grandfather began manufacturing in Peoria, IL. We're known internationally for our iconic Pie Irons sandwich cookers.

How do you cook burgers in a pie iron? ›

Heat the pie iron over the fire. Melt a little fat in the bottom half of the pan and put in the patties (or patty). Close the lid. Cook over coals for 20 to 25 minutes, flipping the pie iron over every five minutes.

How do you cook in a pie iron? ›

The best meal procedure for the pie iron goes like this: grease the pans a little; add a starch, like mashed potatoes, dough, or bread; add fillings; then cover with the same starch. Clasp the irons shut, then lay flat over a bed of hot embers or coals to cook evenly.

What is a pudgy pie? ›

Pudgy pies–also known as mountain pies–are cooked in a pie iron, which is a cast-iron cooking tool that closes, clamshell style, over sandwiches and other stuffed bread.

What is America's number one selling pie? ›

Apple pie is arguably one of the most popular pie flavors. A symbol of America, the apple pie was actually invented by the British.

What is the #1 pie flavor? ›

The clear winner for the United States as a whole was (not surprisingly) apple pie with more than 27% of sales going to the traditional flavor.

Can you use a pie iron on a stove? ›

Models with shorter handles can also be used on the stovetop, especially if you have a gas range. However, even electric stoves work well with pie irons. Even on a rainy day you can have the experience of campfire cooking with a pie iron by your side.

How long to cook with pie iron? ›

Cooking with the pie iron

Place your recipe ingredients into the iron before closing and latching it. Cook the recipe over an open fire. Most recipes take five to ten minutes to cook but times can vary widely depending on how hot the fire is.

Do I need to season my pie iron? ›

When you season your Pie Iron it not only helps prevent oxidation, but helps food from sticking to the iron. light coating of paraffin wax on the iron to protect it from rusting while on the store shelf and in transit to you.

Do you preheat pie iron? ›

Preheating Suggestions: Lay your empty pie iron in the hot coals of your campfire for a couple of minutes to preheat. Always exercise caution when handling pie irons, especially around kids.

How do you clean a pie iron after use? ›

CLEANING & STORAGE: Properly cleaning after use will help ensure that the pie iron will be around for years to come. Start by scraping out of your cooled pie iron any burnt food with a plastic scraper. If necessary, let it soak for 5 minutes in water. Scrub surfaces with just water until all food remnants are gone.

What is Elvis Presley pie? ›

Chef Paula Haney shares with Duff the bakery's recipe for the Fat Elvis Pie, which was inspired by Elvis Presley's love of peanut-butter-and-banana sandwiches. The pie includes chocolate pastry cream, peanut butter filling and slices of banana in a crust made of graham cracker crumbs, dry roasted peanuts and pretzels.

What is a hobo pie maker called? ›

A pie iron—also called pudgy pie iron, sandwich toaster, snackwicher, toastie maker—is a cooking appliance that consists of two hinged concave, round or square, cast iron or aluminium plates on long handles. Its "clamshell" design resembles that of a waffle iron, but without that appliance's honeycomb pattern.

What is Oregon pie? ›

Look and taste. Zigzag Mountain Art/Shutterstock. Per Oregon Berries, the official state pie of the Beaver State is Marionberry Pie. This crop is a purple-black fruit that's long, conical, and decently sized.

What is the most famous pie in the world? ›

The Most Popular Pies Around the World
  • Germany: Strawberry Pie. Joseph Sohm.
  • South Korea: Tomato Pie. Getty Images.
  • Mexico: Pie de Limón (Lemon Pie) ...
  • Australia: No-Bake-Vegan French Silk Pie. ...
  • Spain: Apple Pie Chimichanga. ...
  • UK: Vegetarian Shepherd's Pie. ...
  • France: Zucchini, Goat Cheese and Honey Pie. ...
  • United States: Boston Cream Pie.
Mar 17, 2016

What are the names of pie irons? ›

What are some other terms for a pie iron? Other names for these are Camp Cookers, Hobo Pies, Jaffle Irons, or Pudgy Pies.

What is the most famous pie? ›

Apple Pie. What it is: Somehow both quintessentially English and American, this may be the most famous pie of all. In Britain it goes back to the 1300s, and the earliest recipe includes figs and raisins. Modern recipes tend to consist of apples, sugar, butter and cinnamon encased in shortcrust pastry.

What is another name for a pie iron? ›

A pie iron—also called pudgy pie iron, sandwich toaster, snackwicher, toastie maker—is a cooking appliance that consists of two hinged concave, round or square, cast iron or aluminium plates on long handles. Its "clamshell" design resembles that of a waffle iron, but without that appliance's honeycomb pattern.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Greg Kuvalis

Last Updated:

Views: 5868

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (75 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Greg Kuvalis

Birthday: 1996-12-20

Address: 53157 Trantow Inlet, Townemouth, FL 92564-0267

Phone: +68218650356656

Job: IT Representative

Hobby: Knitting, Amateur radio, Skiing, Running, Mountain biking, Slacklining, Electronics

Introduction: My name is Greg Kuvalis, I am a witty, spotless, beautiful, charming, delightful, thankful, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.